- A new analysis concluded that highly engineered consumables could be as addictive as cigarettes.
- Scientists discovered that these foods are designed to maximize pleasure and speed up the delivery of reinforcing ingredients.
- The habit-forming quality of these foods implies they promote compulsive consumption and disrupt natural hunger cues.
- The researchers recommend that UPFs could be subject to controls akin to those for cigarettes.
Currently, there is no single universal description of UPFs. Certain experts define them as foods that include components you are unlikely to have in a home kitchen, such as emulsifiers and additives.
Many professionals use the NOVA system to define ultraprocessed foods. This describes foods that are “combinations of components, mostly of manufacturing origin, typically made by a set of industrial techniques and methods.”
A fresh analysis featured in The Millbank Quarterly suggested that UPFs are potentially just as habit-forming as cigarettes.
“I concur with this research, as UPFs are deliberately designed to be highly appealing to most individuals,” commented a weight loss specialist not affiliated with the study.
Data from 2023 suggests that more than 73% of the foods available in the US is classified as ultraprocessed.
“Cigarettes and UPFs are not simply whole foods but highly engineered delivery systems engineered deliberately to optimize biological and psychological reinforcement and compulsive consumption,” explained the new study’s research team.
Can UPFs Habit-Forming?
The review combined insights from substance use, historical health policy, and dietary science in order to pinpoint textural and compositional characteristics that increase the reinforcing potential of both tobacco and UPFs.
“Not everyone is ‘addicted’’ to these foods, but for a sizable group, they elicit classic habit-forming patterns: intense desires, inability to stop, and persistent consumption despite negative health effects,” commented a heart health nutrition expert.
“These foods are purposely formulated with processed carbohydrates, extra oils, sodium, and taste additives to optimize pleasure and ongoing intake, and the industry uses persuasive advertising strategies, especially targeting young people,” she continued.
Scientists analyzed five key areas:
- rapid absorption
- pleasure-based design, or creating products to be extremely pleasurable
- perfecting the amount
- environmental ubiquity
- misleading changes, or “wellness branding”
The study concluded that, similar to cigarettes, ultraprocessed foods are carefully calibrated to deliver the optimal amount of sugar.
“Processed carbs stimulate dopamine release via the a key neural pathway, while lipids achieve this through intestinal lipid sensing,” the authors explained.
“… UPFs with high levels of refined carbohydrates and extra oils are some of the most potently rewarding foods in the modern diet. Importantly this refined carbohydrate-fat combination is virtually absent in whole foods.”
The way such products rapidly deliver “feel-good” substances to the mind renders them likely habit-forming, in a comparable way to tobacco.
The review stated that while cigarettes are designed to deliver the addictive compound rapidly, ultraprocessed foods are engineered to be broken down and absorbed quickly, as they usually have minimal fiber. This allows for the system to metabolize lipids and carbohydrates more quickly.
Authors also explain that ultraprocessed foods give deliberate flavor bursts that dissipate rapidly and mouthfeels that dissolve easily. This collectively works to deliver more dopamine and prompts individuals to consume additional amounts.
‘Health Washing’ in Tobacco, Ultraprocessed Foods
According to the review, both the tobacco and processed food sectors have long used a strategy called “health washing.”
This refers to where goods are marketed and reformulated to create an illusion of reduced harm while preserving the essential addictive properties.
This tactic in the cigarette sector gained traction in the 1950s with the advent of filter tips on cigarettes.
They were marketed as safety features that would trap tar and particles before they entered the respiratory system. In reality, these tips offer little meaningful benefit.
Yet, people often adjusted by taking bigger puffs or smoking more frequently, which offset any reduction in toxin exposure.
The food industry has adopted a similar approach. It uses packaging claims such as “reduced fat” or “sugar-free” to promote UPFs.
Yet, these foods often retain the very addictive ingredient combinations. The issue is that these reformulations offer a superficial appearance of wellness while the product’s addictive structure and metabolic harms persist unchanged.
Should UPFs Face Controls?
The authors noted at the end of their review that nourishment and tobacco are not the same thing.
Nevertheless, they warned that certain UPFs act like highly optimized products rather than actual food. They recommended that health regulations should reflect this reality.
“Tobacco provides a cautionary tale, and tobacco control offers a model of potential,” the researchers stated.
Because of regulations, smoking rates in the US have declined and have “reshaped public perception of tobacco and eroded trust in the industry.”
“I believe increased education about the harmful effects of UPFs is essential to lower general consumption and improve population wellness. The strategies employed to reduce tobacco use have been effective and may be a useful model for ultra-processed foods as well,” commented one expert.
“It is not my view ultraprocessed foods ought to be controlled exactly as tobacco, but they do warrant more robust, tobacco-inspired measures: advertising limits, obvious front-of-package labeling, stricter standards on wellness assertions, and limits in schools or medical facilities,” noted another nutrition professional.
The researchers pointed out to people that lightly altered and whole foods have sustained human health for millennia.